California employers generally are aware that workers’ compensation
rates this year
are about 30% lower than they
were in 2005, but
did you also know that
- Rates are going down again July1 for policies renewing on
or after that date- with California and regional insurers cutting
rates from 5% to 10% mostly (State Fund cut rates 10%, Zenith
5%, and national insurers mostly cutting rates 16.4%: Employers
Direct, Zurich, St. Paul/Travelers)
- Based on the first quarter of 2006, insurers
profits are higher than ever even with these lower premiums (just issued
report of WCIRB) with a first quarter “calendar year” loss ratio
reported of only 51% for 2006
- When your workers’ compensation policy comes up for renewal,
be aware that there is an increasing diversity between insurers
on the rates they offer.
Another round of rate cuts has occurred for new
polices going into effect July 1, ‘06.
The 173 California workers’ compensation insurance rate filings
in May and June for July1, 2006 have led to additional rate decreases
ranging from a 5% cut by Zenith the 10% drop by the State Compensation
and the 16.4% rate drop by many national insurers., continuing
a competitive market for employers.
Key May Rate Filings include:
- Berkshire Hathaway’s
- Redwood Fire -6.5%
- National Liability & Fire -7.5%
- Employers Compensation Ins Co. -12.7%
- Comp West -9.9%
- Employers Direct Insurance -16.4%
- Zenith -5%
Key June Rate Filings include:
- State Fund -10%
- Zurich -16.4%
- Liberty Mutual -11%
- St.Paul/Travelers -16.4%
Average Premium Rages: The average
insurer premium rate per $100 of payroll has continued to fall
since 2003, when it
peaked at $ 6.47 per
$100- average across
all payroll classifications. For the first six months of 2005,
the rate had gone down to
$5.34 per $100, and declined to
$4.49 for the last six month of 2005. For the first quarter of 2006,
the average rate has been
$3.75.
Insurance Co. Loss Ratios: But have the
insurers been making a profit with these falling premiums?
ABSOLUTELY YES! Losses are reported in two ways. First by “accident
year”- meaning claims allocated to the year the accident occurred.
Using this method of reporting, the latest loss ratios for
both 2004 and 2005 are approximately 34%- historically
low losses.
The second way of reporting losses uses a calendar method, which
matches the financial reporting of insurance companies in their
quarterly and annual financial reports to regulators and stock
holders. On this basis, the WCIRB reports the 2006
Calendar 1st Quarter Loss Ratio of 51%, if not the lowest loss ratio ever,
at least close to it.
Decline in Claim Frequency: A good part of
the financial success is the result of actions by employers in
providing safer workplaces. The frequency of workes’ compensation
claims has declined continuously since 2000, with
13% fewer claims filed in the past year alone.
For more information and educational tools on health and safety
issues, contact Dressler at info@dondressler.com,
or at (949) 533-3742.